In the year 2000, as the blogosphere was gaining notoriety and people were experimenting with how to use it, four South Koreans did the unthinkable. They released their blog to none other than a professional journalist’s worst nightmare… the average citizen (dun, dun, dun).
So, it wasn’t quite that dramatic. But the effect the launch of their site OhmyNews had on South Korea, its political culture and the blogosphere has been dramatic. Using the slogan, “every citizen is a reporter,” founder Oh Yeon-Ho is attempting to blur the lines between reporter and non-reporter and eventually destroy the concept of journalist and article all together, instead leaving a simple discussion between people.
The site, which in 2003 was composed of a staff of 53 “professionals” (reporters and editors) and more than 25,000 citizen reporters, merges real news with citizen commentary. Yeon-Ho calls the site a “complete demolition of conventional media logic and of the concept of journalists.” It takes the traditional model of news media and turns it upside down; news starts from the bottom up rather than top down.
But that isn’t all.
OhmyNews quickly gained notoriety among Web users, so much so that it is believed to have influenced the popular vote of the country to elect of President Roh Moo-hyun in 2003.
The lack of objectivity in a news blog as opposed to a traditional news source made this possible. OhmyNews covered the popularity of President Roh, especially within young voting demographics. Yeon-Ho described the change as a “desire for the reformation of politics,” if there hadn’t have been a desire for change, the political side of the site wouldn’t have taken off or had the effect it did.
Our country faces a similar issue today. The appearance of campaign websites in the early 1990s and the influence of news and citizen blogs are changing the face of politics.
Issues and appearances that may have been minor before are now discussed between citizens and incorporated within traditional news media on a constant basis. Citizens are filling the gaps traditional news organizations leave out leaving not a single aspect of the process or the candidates unanalyzed.
But, this is not necessarily negative. Competition between real journalists and citizen journalists means improved quality, says Yeon-Ho. “When a New York Times reporter writes an article and an ordinary citizen – whether he is a professor or neighbor – writes an article criticizing it splendidly, then the citizen becomes the winner.”
Though sites like OhmyNews may be a professional journalists’ worst nightmare, the redefinition they bring to the field means more voices and more discussion and, for us, a better democracy.
Discussion Questions:
Why does the blogosphere have the ability to influence elections, specifically in countries like South Korea? Why does it work in America and how does it differ?
How do you foresee mixing citizen and traditional journalist voices will affect our country in ways aside from politics?

[...] (2 – Faith) Outing, S. (2005, June 13). The 11 layers of citizen journalism. PoynterOnline. * (3 – Whitney B) Yeon-Jung, Y. (2003, Sept. 17). OhMyNews Makes Every Citizen A Reporter. Japan Media [...]
By: week 5 - blogs as citizen journalism « Social Technologies, Media and Politics on April 29, 2008
at 10:16 am
Since South Korea learned about democracy with the emergence of digital technology, perhaps OhMyNews wasn’t that big of an innovation after all. Since South Korea is most likely the most wired nation in the world, many (and I mean many) Koreans have the ability to access a computer, or get online through their cellphone, or PDA. If everyone has a camera phone, then getting the news is easy – take the picture or record the video, upload it to the OhMyNews Web site and walla! You have just journalized! It sounds wicked cool!
By: Lorin on April 29, 2008
at 12:12 pm
Interesting point, I hadn’t thought about the lack of free press in Korea. With these types of blogs in our culture now, why do you think its taken off so well in the U.S.? Good Pontification!
By: Lorin on May 1, 2008
at 10:32 am
Why does the blogosphere have the ability to influence elections, specifically in countries like South Korea? Why does it work in America and how does it differ?
The reason may be that people trust in the grassroots more. They feel a connection with other ordinary white collar workers and netizens. They rather listen to someone whom they can connect with than the politicians, who seem really far away and “up there” and may not understand their problems. And every politician have their own agenda and PR motives, what they said may be all euphemism. The blogosphere serves as a filter that puts politics into real world perspectives that deals with the fundamental bread and butter issues. That is perhaps why people are more inclined to listen to the opinions of the bloggers during elections.
By: huifenh on May 6, 2008
at 4:53 pm
Great post Whitney-
I agree with the last post that mentioned the point that people hold faith in grass roots. We are often times more opt to believe in those who are more like us. So when comparing citizen journalism to traditional journalism, it seems like people read and listen to tradtional sources, but go back to the blogosphere to get validated. To fill in those gaps and move beyond media fluff.
Also, to go along with Lorin’s comment, South Korea has to be one of the most technologically advanced places to date, and with sources such as “Oh my News” it was bound to happen at some point. Although citizen journalism can be detrimental to traditional journalists, I believe that we are just on the cusp of the capabilites that we as every day citizens can contribute to the news world. We are now able to get more stories, more points of view, a whole lot faster then we could with a few journalists on a particular story.
By: Jessica Levold on May 7, 2008
at 8:53 am
Whitney, your blog post inspired me to do a little research on OnmyNews. A google news search lead me to this interesting article by PBS’s Frontline News about the history and story of OhmyNews. Check it out here: http://www.pbs.org/frontlineworld/rough/2007/03/south_korea.html (sorry, I don’t know HTML to code in the hypertext link!)
The PBS story documents the life of Vanessa Hua, a journalist who traveled to South Korea to study OhmyNews and the impact of everyday citizen reporters. It is really interesting and worth the read.
Thank you for introducing me to this topic and for your insight.
By: whitney on May 7, 2008
at 10:06 pm
I hope that the “professional” journalists in the United States learn to celebrate the growth of blogging and campaign websites and its technology like the citizens in South Korea. Yesterday, I met a man who was the producer for the online portion of The Seattle Times. One of my classmates posed a question on blogs and the guest speaker could only say negative things about blogs. Saying that the term blog was meaningless and uncredible. He went on to say that online newspapers would soon dominate the blogs and that blogs will not last in the long run.
I feel that the people who “control” what media is shown to the public should be more openminded, and your post certainly shows what such an open-mindess can do to a country. Jessica also brings up a few positives about if the media and blogosphere did pair up. The two systems would greater benefit society and democracy.
By: nicology on May 7, 2008
at 11:27 pm
Thanks for the great comments guys! Nicole, I think it’s really interesting that you mentioned someone working in the news industry was so closed minded about the blogosphere. I think that OhmyNews is the perfect example of how traditional media and blogs can coexist, be credible and influence politics. I think its naive to not see blogging as where media is going (or at least what it is going to converge with). Maybe part of the reason is as huifenh said, that average citizens trust average citizens especially when it comes to their news. Perhaps big media should take a step back to see that it can fit into the new system of news, it just has to adapt to the blogosphere in the process.
By: Whitney on May 8, 2008
at 5:32 pm
Hi Whitney, I know you are interested in pursuing a career in journalism after graduation. Would you ever consider a career as a blogger for a newspaper? If so, i think you should start your own blog. Your are a good writer and it would be a great “living resume” for your portfolio. Just a thought
By: tynerw on May 11, 2008
at 3:55 pm
Whitney and Nicology — you both agreed that part of th reason average citizens trust average citizens especially when it comes to their news because they can relate to them better; however, I feel like I would be less likely to trust an article written by an average though rather than a professional journalist. By turning news into a community discussion, isn’t there an issue of conflicting stories or unbalanced reports? I think I can relate to journalists feeling threatened by blogs like Ohmynews because I feel that if if a site like that would lose credibility it could negatively impact traditional journalists trying to make their way. Also, how do sites like Ohmynews change how journalists/news organizations make money? Since everyone can contribute, is anyone paid/on staff?
By: Kendra on May 12, 2008
at 9:44 am
Tynerw — I agree that Whitney is a great writer and should start her own blog! I too plan to go into the news industry in the future, and after taking this class and learning the important role blogs will play in our future, I plan to continue blogging too. Now I just need to find a topic that I feel passionate about continuing writing about…
By: Kendra on May 12, 2008
at 10:30 am
Kendra — I liked how you questioned the credibility and conflicting issues of blogs. In this weeks reading from Dispatches From Blogistan, Stefanac talks about how hyperlinks are the links to truth and that bloggers should have links in each of their posts so people can see where they got their information. This is a way to make blogs more credible, although I think some other ways should also be developed. To make money, businesses and organizations should create their own blogs and hire employees to maintain those blogs. So instead of looking at other people for information, they can take out the middlemen and do that on their own.
To answer your money question, I feel that sites such as Ohmynews save money since if the issuing is pressing enough, people are just going to post to get their opinion out there – money isn’t a driving force. So newspapers who get their information from this site are getting people’s thoughts and what information they bring to the table for free. But I am sure they do pay a few people to monitor the site. Advertising is probably a large moneymaker, and maybe the political parties will give the site money to cover events.
By: nicology on May 12, 2008
at 11:13 pm